ENERGY TRANSITION

My night with Miss America 2023

Our editor didn't know what to expect when the pro-nuclear circus came to town

My night with Miss America 2023

Credits: Nuclear for Australia

It was a night of opposites and omissions as nuclear energy advocate and former Miss America Grace Stanke came to Perth to spruik the controversial energy option. 

As reported in ENB, nuclear energy and influencer Stanke is on a whirlwind tour of Australia, speaking at a series of events hosted by the Dick Smith-funded Nuclear for Australia. 

Perth was Stanke's first engagement – just hours after landing from a long-haul flight from the US.  

While it was well attended and organised, the age difference between Stanke and Will Shankel—her 18-year-old host and the organiser of Nuclear for Australia—and the evening's decidedly late-middle-aged (mainly male) audience could not have been more stark.  

Credits: Nuclear for Australia

There were also no dissenting voices—not one. 

At just 22 years old, Stanke spoke with confidence and enthusiasm about her journey to becoming what the Wall Street Journal described as the new face of nuclear energy. 

As a 16-year-old considering university courses, she admitted her naivety about nuclear concepts. 

"I knew nothing about nuclear. I knew bombs in World War Two from history class, and I was like, there's maybe two nuclear reactors in America. Maybe absolute maximum. No way. There's more. No way. 

"What a flex it would be to say I'm a nuclear engineer. Imagine a high school class reunion - I will definitely win best career. I better because how do you top a nuclear engineer? My runner-up option was rocket scientist, but nuclear engineers seemed cooler," she enthused. 

Stanke rattled off the well-rehearsed figures during a 20-minute presentation. She explained that America's 94 reactors provide 20% of the nation's power, leading to 6% lower bills for nearby communities.  

She pointed out that radioactivity is actually present in everyday stuff like bananas, avocados, and even smoke alarms. And just to really drive the point home, she threw out: "You know, working in a nuclear power plant is actually safer than working in a grocery store." 

Credits: Fraser Maywood

Following that, Shankel hosted a Q&A with Stanke, who sat alongside Mark Schneider, UBH Group's Chief Nuclear Officer, Jasmin Diab, president of Women in Nuclear (WiN) Australia, and Nate Smith, CEO of nuclear waste management at Tellus Holdings. 

While it might be expected that an evening arranged purely to advocate for a nuclear-powered Australia might be light on critical voices, the total lack of dissenting questions was glaring. 

All the usual supportive arguments were heard about how nuclear energy is a clean and safe technology ideally suited to Australia's geology and geography.

Heck, according to Smith, even nuclear waste disposal is a doozy. 

But even when Diab was asked how long it might take to build a nuclear power plant in Australia, the elephant in the room was left ignored. 

"If you could lift the ban tomorrow, get legislation through Parliament, you could start doing your site feasibility studies, your social license, your upskilling of a workforce, going out to tender to see what designs are most appropriate - that would take about three to four years, potentially five years, to do all of that properly.  

"You could then turn dirt and have neutrons on the grid seven to 10 years later," she said matter-of-factly. 

So, the president of Women in Nuclear Australia says we could have a reactor in 10 years at best and 15 years at worst.  

And that's once the political and regulatory issues have been magicked away. 

"And what's Australia meant to do in the meantime?" asked the lonely elephant.

A growing series of reports, each focused on a key discussion point for the energy sector, brought to you by the Energy News Bulletin Intelligence team.

A growing series of reports, each focused on a key discussion point for the energy sector, brought to you by the Energy News Bulletin Intelligence team.

editions

Future of Energy Report: Nuclear Power in Australia 2024

Energy News Bulletin’s new report examines what the energy and resources industry thinks of the idea of a nuclear-powered Australia.

editions

ENB CCS Report 2024

ENB’s CCS Report 2024 finds that CCS could be the much-needed magic bullet for Australia’s decarbonisation drive

editions

ENB Cost Report 2023

ENB’s latest Cost Report findings provide optimism as investments in oil and gas, as well as new energy rise.

editions

ENB Future of Energy Report 2023

ENB’s inaugural Future of Energy Report details the industry outlook on the medium-to-long-term future for the sector in the Asia Pacific region.